I am astonished at this negative review of Ailish Tynan's singing. I bought the CD as the result of a BBC radio show that named this performance of 'Shepherd on the Rock' as one of the recordings of the year, and I was not disappointed. I think she is one of the finest modern interpreters of this much loved piece and if the first reviewer's level of knowledge of coloratura singing matches the inaccurate spelling of it, I am not surprised that they failed to recognise her impressive articulation.